© 2007-2024

3 Must-Haves for the Best Nonprofit Websites

Table of Contents

A nonprofit website is the digital home for your cause. Whether your operations are small or widespread, most of your community will interact with your nonprofit primarily through your website. It serves as your digital headquarters. When a new donor wants to determine if you’re the right organization to support, they’ll visit your website. When community members in need of your services seek help, your website is their first stop.

In the modern world, visiting a brand’s website often precedes making any other decision. Thus, your nonprofit website design is one of the most important tools for connecting with donors, volunteers, and the communities you support. Here are three essential traits every nonprofit website must have.

3 Must-Haves for Every Nonprofit Website

  1. Traffic & Discoverability
  2. Conversion-Optimized Design
  3. Time-Saving Features

Without these three elements, your website will fall short of its potential to reach and support your community effectively. Let’s dive into what it takes to achieve these goals.

Enhance Discoverability

Your nonprofit’s effectiveness is closely tied to its reach—both in attracting donors and volunteers and in connecting with the communities you serve. Every nonprofit website should aim for maximum reach, as support can come from anywhere. To achieve this, you need to engage in SEO (Search Engine Optimization), content marketing, and ensure top-notch website performance.

SEO, SEM, and Technical SEO

Your SEO strategy hinges on keyword targeting, determining when your website appears in search results. The more relevant search terms you target, the greater your reach. SEO goes beyond keywords; it includes SEM (Search Engine Marketing) and technical SEO, which involve comprehensive strategies to make Google prioritize your website over others with similar keywords.

Content Marketing and Community Building

Content marketing transforms your website’s pages into tools for outreach. Your blog, service pages, success stories, testimonials, and event pages can all become sources of content marketing. Create content that attracts future donors, volunteers, and community members, enticing them to engage with your site.

Website Performance and Accessibility

Website performance has a dual purpose: fast, mobile-responsive sites are prioritized in search results, and they also improve accessibility, allowing more people to engage with your nonprofit. Ensure your site loads quickly and is easy to navigate to maximize reach and engagement.

Generate Consistent Positive Traffic

Create a community on your website where people can meet and chat, use helpful tools, and read interesting stories. The more traffic your site generates, the stronger its appearance in search results will be.

Create Guided Conversion Paths

The second essential trait of a nonprofit website is its ability to convert visitors into supporters. Optimize for conversion by crafting paths that guide visitors smoothly from arrival to decision-making, minimizing friction along the way.

Choose a Core Call to Action

Select a primary call to action (CTA) for your homepage. This could be making a donation, signing up for a newsletter, joining a volunteer group, or purchasing an event ticket. Place this CTA front and center and create a simple, rewarding path for users to follow.

Donor and Volunteer Paths

Many visitors will come knowing they want to donate or volunteer. Make it easy for them with clear, uplifting paths. Include ‘Donate’ and ‘Volunteer’ options in your top navigation bar, each leading to a landing page with straightforward choices like donation tiers or upcoming events.

Guide New Community Members

Ensure smooth conversion paths for new community members seeking assistance. Tailor the language and imagery to match your nonprofit’s mission and audience. Test these paths frequently to ensure they are as welcoming and efficient as possible.

Create Content for Each Conversion Path

Inbound marketing content can enhance your conversion funnel. Volunteer content might include “How to Help” articles, while donor content could feature success stories highlighting the impact of donations.

Save Time at Every Stage

The third must-have is time-saving features. People engage with nonprofits to make a difference easily. Ensure your website design helps users save time at every step, from navigation to signing up and donating.

Simple, Intuitive Navigation

Keep menus simple and compartmentalize extensive content. Organize blogs into a navigable archive and turn features into a user portal. Use a site map and breadcrumbs to help users navigate easily.

Easy-to-Use Features

Test your website rigorously to ensure ease of use. Include accessibility features like high-contrast modes and text-to-speech options. Keep buttons big and touch-friendly, and ensure menus and features are simple and quick.

Fast Sign-Up Processes

Simplify sign-ups with options like Google, Facebook, and Apple logins for one-click account creation. Keep the process on-site and welcoming.

Easy and Rewarding Donations

Make donations smooth and fast with one-click amounts and various payment options like PayPal, Venmo, and CashApp.

Efficient Volunteer Onboarding

Make volunteer scheduling and onboarding seamless with embedded scheduling apps and clear prep lists. Show photos of past events to build excitement.

Welcoming Returning Members

Implement loyalty program features that remember past donors and volunteers. Greet them by name, remember their preferences, and make repeat actions easy.

Nonprofit Website Design is Paramount

Your nonprofit website is crucial for connecting with your community, attracting new donors and volunteers, and coordinating events. By focusing on discoverability, conversions, and time-saving features, you can elevate your nonprofit’s digital presence. Contact us today for expert nonprofit website design services tailored to your organization’s unique needs.

Free Business Audit

Discover your business’s online ranking, identify growth opportunities, and determine the best advertising strategies for your business. Submit a request, and we’ll analyze your case for free within three business days.


us a Line


Have a project in mind? Send a message.

© 2007-2024 Zayats Design. All right reserved

Thank You for Joining Our Referral Program!

We have sent you an email with all the details about the program. Please check your inbox for your unique referral code and instructions on how to start earning rewards.

If you do not receive the email within a few minutes, please check your spam or junk folder. If you still can’t find it, contact us at collab@zayatsdesign.com.

Thank you for your support!


Additional services

Let’s create something great together!

© 2007-2024 Zayats Design. All right reserved

Skip to content